Navigating Insurance Denials and Filing Appeals

Insurance denials can be frustrating. It can leave you feeling helpless in the face of health concerns. It’s important to remember that you have rights as a policyholder. There are steps you can take to advocate for yourself. Take control of your healthcare journey.

Here’s what you need to know to navigate insurance denials and the appeal process.

Denials vs. appeals

Healthcare denials and appeals are integral parts of the health insurance process.

  • A denial is when your insurance company rejects your claim for coverage.
  • An appeal is the process of challenging that denial.
health insurance claim form, calculator, and pen

Healthcare denials

A healthcare denial occurs when an insurance company refuses to provide coverage. The denial could be for a medical treatment, procedure, or medication. Denials can occur for various reasons, including:

  • Optional medical care or lack of medical necessity
  • Out-of-network care
  • Error in medical coding
  • Not covered under your policy
  • Pre-existing conditions

The health insurer sends the denial letter to the patient and the healthcare provider. The letter explains the reasons for the denial. It also includes instructions and next steps for submitting your appeal.

Healthcare appeals

A healthcare appeal is when a patient or provider challenges a coverage denial. The goal of the appeal is to overturn the denial and secure coverage of the treatment or medical procedure.

Unhappy woman at her kitchen counter holding a "prescription denied" paper. There are other medications in front of her.

Why do insurance denials occur?

Insurance companies deny claims or coverage for various reasons, including:

  1. Lack of medical necessity. Insurance companies may reject claims they deem not necessary. This may occur when the insurance company considers the treatment to be new, untested or not supported by medical evidence. In some cases, the claim may be denied because it may not meet specific criteria in the insurance policy.
  2. Incorrect coding. Errors in medical coding can lead to claim denials. Medical coding is the process of putting a patient’s medical information into codes. Every diagnosis, procedure, and medical service has a code. These codes can be incorrect due to human error. Incorrect coding can result in rejected claims. Incomplete information or discrepancies between the billed services and the medical records can also lead to claim denials.
  3. Out-of-network providers. If you receive care from an out-of-network provider, your claim may be denied or paid at a lower rate.
  4. Pre-existing condition exclusions. Some policies have exclusions for pre-existing conditions. This could result in denial of coverage for certain treatments. Make sure you understand the terms of your policy about pre-existing conditions. This way you can help avoid unexpected denials.
  5. Policy limitations and exclusions. Insurance policies often have limitations and exclusions. These could be for certain treatments, procedures, or services. The limitations may depend on the type of policy and the insurance provider. It’s important to review your policy to understand what is covered and what is not.

Learning the common reasons for claim denials can help you prevent denials for medical services. It can help you navigate the appeals process if a denial does happen. Stay informed and advocate for yourself.

How do healthcare insurance denials affect patients?

Healthcare insurance denials can have a significant impact on patients seeking medical services.

  1. Delayed or denied care. Denials of coverage can result in delays or denials of necessary medical treatment. This can impact your health and well-being. Delayed treatment can lead to poor health. It can also raise healthcare costs in the long run.
  2. Financial burden. Patients may have higher out-of-pocket expenses due to a denied claim. The financial burden can be substantial for expensive treatments or procedures.
  3. Stress and frustration. Dealing with health insurance coverage denials can be stressful and frustrating. The appeals process can be time-consuming and complex. This can add to the emotional burden of managing a health condition.
Two people are sitting at a table. One person's hands, dressed in a white coat, are gently resting on another's hands, offering reassurance. A clipboard with a form detailing health insurance options, alongside a pen and laptop, is visible on the table.

The role of your healthcare provider

A healthcare insurance denial is discouraging, but you don’t have to navigate the appeals process alone. Your healthcare provider can be a valuable ally in your efforts to overturn the denial. When you receive a denial notice, work with your healthcare provider to file an appeal.

Your healthcare provider can…

  1. Provide records. Your provider can supply essential records to support your appeal. These might include medical records, treatment plans, test results, and notes. These documents help explain why the treatment or procedure is necessary, strengthening your case with the insurance company.
  2. Write letters of medical necessity. Insurance companies often deny claims because they believe a medical treatment may not be necessary. Your healthcare provider can write a detailed letter explaining why the treatment is essential. This letter can include information about your…
    • Medical history
    • Diagnosis
    • Prognosis
    • Expected outcome of the recommended treatment
  3. Advocate on your behalf. Healthcare providers can advocate for you during the appeals process. They can talk to the insurance company, provide more information, answer questions, and address concerns. Their expertise and supporting documents can help persuade the insurance company to reconsider.
  4. Offer different solutions. Your healthcare provider can work with you to explore different treatment options or a treatment plan that your insurance covers.

Tips for working with your healthcare provider

  1. Be open and honest. Update your healthcare provider throughout the appeals process. Tell them your concerns, questions, and preferences. Be open to their guidance and suggestions.
  2. Provide all necessary information: Ensure that your healthcare provider has access to all relevant information and records. This may include any conversations with the insurance company, records of your previous treatments, medications, and medical history.
  3. Follow through with suggestions. Follow up on any suggestions or instructions provided by your healthcare provider. These suggestions may include:
    • scheduling follow-up appointments;
    • providing more records;
    • looking at alternative treatment options.
  4. Stay informed. Check in often on your appeal. Ask questions if you’re unsure about any part of the process.

Remember, you are not in this alone. Work with your healthcare provider to navigate the appeals process. A doctor’s expertise and support can increase your chances of overturning the denial.

Illustration of a health insurance concept. A large document labeled "Health Insurance" is surrounded by icons representing healthcare, such as a shield, a syringe, medicine, and money. A man and a woman are interacting with the elements.

Steps to advocate for yourself

Getting a healthcare denial can feel like hitting a roadblock on your path to wellness. It’s a setback, but it’s important to remember that you have options. If you need to submit an appeal independently, here are some tips to help you get through the process with confidence.

  1. Review the denial letter. Read the denial letter from your insurance company carefully. Jot down the claim number. Be sure to understand the reason the insurance claim was denied. Pay attention to the specific policy guidelines mentioned in the letter. Take note of the deadlines for filing an appeal. Missing the deadlines could hurt your chances of overturning the denial.
  2. Contact your healthcare provider. Reach out to your healthcare provider to discuss the denial. Review the claim denial letter together. Ask your provider to forward any records that can support your appeal. The provider may be able to respond on your behalf and advocate for you.
  3. Gather records. Gather all relevant documents to support your case. This may include medical records, treatment plans, medications, and messages with healthcare providers. If it was an error in coding or billing, find evidence to show that your claim is accurate.
  4. Understand your policy. Review your insurance policy. Understand the coverage limitations, exclusions, and appeals process. This can help empower you to go through the advocacy process.
  5. Contact your insurance company. Reach out to your insurance company to request information about the appeals process. Ask about the necessary steps to file an appeal and what supporting evidence is needed. Your insurer should provide you with guidance on where to submit your appeal. Find out what records and documents are required as part of the appeal.
  6. Write a detailed appeal letter. Your appeal letter should include the specific explanation for the denial. Then provide evidence to support your case. Your letter should be clear and concise. It should include relevant policy provisions or medical guidelines to help your appeal. 
  7. Submit your appeal. Submit your appeal to the insurance company by the deadline. Make sure you include all necessary documents and records. Keep copies of everything for your records, including the proof of delivery.
  8. Follow up. Follow up with the insurance company to track the status of your appeal. You want to make sure the appeal is processed on time. Be persistent and advocate for yourself until a final decision is made.
  9. Find help. If the insurance company denies your appeal, consider asking for help. Patient advocacy groups, legal aid services, or state insurance departments can help. These resources can provide guidance and support for the appeals process.

Remember, you are your own best advocate. You know the treatments and medical services you need for your health. Your voice matters in the fight for insurance coverage.

Developed in partnership with:

Logo of the National Association of Medication Access & Patient Advocacy (NAMAPA). It features a purple cross with a syringe, IV bag, and capsule on the left, next to the organization's name on the right.

Supported by: 

The image shows the Amgen logo in bold blue letters.